Failed to create voting files on disk group RECOC1

Long story short, faced this issue while running OneCommand for one Exadata system. The step (Initialize Cluster Software) was failing with the following error on the screen

Checking file on node
Error: Error running root scripts, please investigate…
Collecting diagnostics…
Errors occurred. Send /u01/onecommand/linux-x64/WorkDir/ to Oracle to receive assistance.

Doesn’t make much sense. So let us check the log file of this step

2017-04-27 18:17:10,463 [INFO][  OCMDThread][        ClusterUtils:413] Checking file root_dm01dbadm02.somedomain.com_2017-04-27_18-13-27.log on node
2017-04-27 18:17:10,464 [INFO][  OCMDThread][        OcmdException:62] Error: Error running root scripts, please investigate…
2017-04-27 18:17:10,464 [FINE][  OCMDThread][        OcmdException:63] Throwing OcmdException… message:Error running root scripts, please investigate…

So we need to go to log file now. That shows

Failed to create voting files on disk group RECOC1.
Change to configuration failed, but was successfully rolled back.
CRS-4000: Command Replace failed, or completed with errors.
Voting file add failed
2017/04/27 18:16:37 CLSRSC-261: Failed to add voting disks

Died at /u01/app/ line 2068.
The command ‘/u01/app/ -I/u01/app/ -I/u01/app/ /u01/app/ ‘ execution failed

Makes some senses but we can’t understand what happened while creating Voting files on RECOC1. Let us check ASM alert log also

NOTE: Creating voting files in diskgroup RECOC1
Thu Apr 27 18:16:36 2017
NOTE: Voting File refresh pending for group 1/0x39368071 (RECOC1)
Thu Apr 27 18:16:36 2017
NOTE: Attempting voting file creation in diskgroup RECOC1
NOTE: voting file allocation (replicated) on grp 1 disk RECOC1_CD_00_DM01CELADM01
NOTE: voting file allocation on grp 1 disk RECOC1_CD_00_DM01CELADM01
NOTE: voting file allocation (replicated) on grp 1 disk RECOC1_CD_00_DM01CELADM02
NOTE: voting file allocation on grp 1 disk RECOC1_CD_00_DM01CELADM02
NOTE: voting file allocation (replicated) on grp 1 disk RECOC1_CD_00_DM01CELADM03
NOTE: voting file allocation on grp 1 disk RECOC1_CD_00_DM01CELADM03
ERROR: Voting file allocation failed for group RECOC1
Thu Apr 27 18:16:36 2017
Errors in file /u01/app/oracle/diag/asm/+asm/+ASM1/trace/+ASM1_ora_228588.trc:
ORA-15274: Not enough failgroups (5) to create voting files

So we can see the issue here. We can look at the above trace file also for more detail.

Now to why did this happen ?

The RECOC1 is a HIGH redundancy disk group which means that if we want to place Voting files there, it should have at least 5 failure groups. In this configuration there are only 3 cells and that doesn’t meet the minimum failure groups condition (1 cell = 1 failgroup in Exadata).

Now to how did it happen ?

This one was an Exadata X3 half rack and we planned to deploy it (for testing purpose) as 2 quarter racks : 1st cluster with db1, db2 + cell1, cell2, cell3 and 2nd cluster with db3, db4 + cell4, cell5, cell6, cell7. All the disk groups to be in High redundancy.

Before a certain 12.x Exadata software version it was not even possible to have all disk groups in High redundancy in a quarter rack as to have Voting disk in a High redundancy disk group you need to have a minimum of 5 failure groups (as mentioned above). In a quarter rack you have only 3 fail groups. With a certain 12.x Exadata software version a new feature quorum disks was introduced which made is possible to have that configuration. Read this link for more details. Basically we take a slice of disk from each DB node and add it to the disk group where you want to have the Voting file. 3 cells + 2 disks from DB nodes makes it 5 so all is good.

Now while starting with the deployment we noticed that db node1 was having some hardware issues. As we needed the machine for testing so we decided to build the first cluster with 1 db node only. So the final configuration of 1st cluster had 1 db node + 3 cells. We imported the XML back in OEDA, modified the cluster 1 configuration to 1 db node and generated the configuration files. That is where the problem started. The RECO disk group still was High redundancy but as we had only 1 db node at this stage so the configuration was not even a candidate for quorum disks. Hence the above error. Changing DBFS_DG to Normal redundancy fixed the issue as when DBFS_DG is Normal redundancy, OneCommand will place the Voting files there.

Ideally it shouldn’t happened as OEDA shouldn’t allow a configuration that is not doable. The case here is that as originally the configuration was having 2 db nodes + 3 cells so High redundancy for all disk groups was allowed in OEDA. While modifying the configuration when one db node was removed from the cluster, OEDA probably didn’t run the redundancy check on disk groups and it allowed the go past that screen. If you try to create a new configuration with 1 db node + 3 cells, it will now allow you to choose High redundancy for all disk groups. DBFS will remain in Normal redundancy. You cant change that.

OneCommand Step 1 error

Hit this silly issue while doing an Exadata deployment for a customer. Step 1 was giving the following error:

ERROR: configured on as dm01dbadm02 does not match expected value

I wasn’t able to make sense of it for quite some time until a colleague pointed out that the reverse lookup entries should be done for FQDN only. As it is clear in the above message reverse lookup of the IP returns dm01dbadm02 instead of Fixing this in DNS resolved the issue.

Actually the customer had done reverse lookup entries for both the hostname and FQDN. As the DNS can return the results in any order, so the error message was bit random. Whenever the the hostname was returned first, Step 1 gave an error. But when the FQDN was the first thing returned, there was no error in Step 1 for that IP., failed and IB listener

So this customer has an Exadata quarter rack and they have an IB listener configured on both DB nodes (for DB connections from a multi-racked Exalogic system). We were adding a new DB node to this rack. So just followed the standard procedure of creating users, directories etc on the new node, setting up ssh equivalence and running All went fine but failed. Little looking into the logs revealed that it failed while running srvctl start listener –n <node_name>

If we manually run this command, it will immediately reveal what the problem is. It is not able to start IB listener on the new node as the IB VIP doesn’t yet exist. It could happen for any of the additional networks added.

There is a MOS note that describes this exact situation but the solution that it gives is to remove the additional listener, complete & and add the additional listener back. That wasn’t possible in this case. After little bit of googling I stumbled upon this post by Jeremy Schneider. His colleague solved this problem with a very simple and clever workaround. Before prepares to run srvctl start listener command, run the add VIP command from another Window Winking smile. Additional network would have already got added when runs on the new node.

To be able to perform this trick, you have to have the hosts file updated with the new VIP name and IP and be ready with the command to add the VIP. While is running, it will show a message like “there is already an active cluster, restarting to join”, immediately start trying to run srvctl add vip command in another window. The moment CRS, comes up the command will succeed. Immediately after that is going to run srvctl start listener command, and this time it shouldn’t fail as the VIP is already added.

Another small mistake we made was not updating the cellip.ora on the new node before running That caused the to fail as it couldn’t talk to ASM running on existing cell nodes. Updating cellip.ora with the existing storage node IPs fixed the problem.

OEDA–Things to keep an eye on

So if you are filling an OEDA for Exadata deployment there are few things you should take care of. Most of the screens are self explanatory but there are some bits where one should focus little more. I am running the Aug version of it and the screenshots below are from that version.

  1. On the Define customer networks screen, the client network is the actual network where your data is going to flow. So typically it is going to be bonded (for high availability) and depending upon the network in your data center you have to select one out of 1/10 G copper and 10 G optical.


  2. If you are going to use trunk VLANs for your client network, remember to enabled it by clicking the Advanced button and then entering the relevant VLAN id.
  3. image

    Also if it is going to be an OVM configuration, you may want to have different VMs in different VLAN segments. It will allow you to change VLAN ids for individual VMs on the respective cluster screens like below


  4. If all the cores aren’t licensed remember to enable Capacity on Demand (COD) on the Identify Compute node OS screen.
  5. image

  6. On the Define clusters screen make sure that you enter a unique (across your environment) cluster name.


  7. The cluster details screen captures some of the most important details like
    1. Whether you want to have flash cache in WriteBack mode instead of WriteThrough
    2. Whether you want to have a role separated install or want to install both GI and Oracle binaries with oracle user itself.
    3. GI & Database versions and home for binaries. Always good to leave it at the Oracle recommended values as that makes the future maintenance easy and less painful.
    4. Disk Group names, redundancy and the space allocation.
    5. Default database name and type (OLTP or DW).


Of course it is important to carefully fill the information in all the screens but the above ones are some of them which should be filled very carefully after capturing the required information from other teams, if needed.

ORA-56841: Master Diskmon cannot connect to a CELL

Faced this error while querying v$asm_disk after adding new storage cell IPs to cellip.ora on DB nodes of an existing cluster on Exadata. Query ends with ORA-03113 end-of-file on communication channel and ORA-56841 is reported in $ORA_CRS_HOME/log/<hostname>/diskmon/diskmon.log. Reason in my case was that the new cell was using different subnet for IB. It was pingable from the db nodes but querying v$asm_disk wasn’t working. Changing the subnet for IB on new cell to the one on existing cells fixed the issue.